Four Kissing Circles

Today we shall explore a more classical configuration which has been studied in various settings — most notably in terms of inversion. We consider \omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3 and \omega_4 (with centers O_1, O_2, O_3 and O_4) to be four circles such that \omega_i and \omega_{i+1} are externally tangent for all 1 \le i \le 4 where indices are considered \pmod{4}.

We shall refer to the following diagram for notation. Since most labels are not standard, the precise definition of each point is given where it is introduced.

A summary of the key results pertaining to this configuration,

  1. Points L,M,N and K denote the tangency points of each pair of circles. An easy angle chase or an inversion about L shows that quadrilateral LMNK is degenerate or cyclic, which is Problem 24 in Chapter 8 of Evan Chen’s EGMO and has also appeared as 2004 Indonesia MO Problem 4.
    • Moreover, this implies that the length of the tangents from LM \cap KN to \omega_2 and \omega_4 as well as the length of the tangents from LK \cap MN to \omega_1 and \omega_2 are equal, which is the statement of 1999 Argentina TST Problem 2.
    • Since the sum of opposite sides of O_1O_2O_3O_4 is equal to the sum of the radii of the circles, by Pitot’s theorem it follows that O_1O_2O_3O_4 is a tangential quadrilateral.
    • Clearly, the perpendicular bisector of segment LK is the internal \angle O_4O_1O_2 bisector and similarly, so it follows that the circumcenter O of LMNK coincides with the incenter of O_1O_2O_3O_4.
    • Congruency arguments show that LMNK is a rectangle if and only if \omega_1,\omega_3 and \omega_2,\omega_4 are pairs of equiradial circles. In particular, when this happens O_1O_2O_3O_4 is a rhombus, and the incircle of this rhombus coincides with (LMNK). In this case, the antipodes of L, M, N and K in \omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3 and \omega_4 (whenever they are defined) all lie on an ellipse with center O.
    • Strengthening this observation, LMNK is a square if and only if all four circles are equiradial, which is asked in 2014 Kukin MO Grade 10 Problem 3.
  2. For any point P \in \{L,M,N,K\} denote by I_P the incenter of the triangle formed by the other three points.
    • By the Incenter/Excenter lemma it follows that quadrilateral LMI_KI_N (and similarly) is concyclic with circumcenter coinciding with the minor LM arc midpoint in (LMNK).
    • Further, an easy angle chase shows that all angles of quadrilateral I_MI_NI_KI_L are right and hence a rectangle.
  3. For any point P \in \{L,M,N,K\} denote by H_P the orthocenter of the triangle formed by the other three points.
    • It is not hard to see that quadrilateral LMH_KH_N (and similarly) is concyclic, and that quadrilateral H_MH_NH_KH_L is also concyclic.
    • The quadrilaterals H_MK_KMK (and similarly) are all parallelograms, which implies that the segments H_MM,H_LL, H_NN and H_KK concur, bisecting each other. This claim is in fact also true for any set of four concyclic points.

Comments

One response to “Four Kissing Circles”

  1. Nico N9 Avatar

    this config looks something new to me

    Like

Leave a Reply