Four Kissing Circles

Today we shall explore a more classical configuration which has been studied in various settings — most notably in terms of inversion. We consider \omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3 and \omega_4 (with centers O_1, O_2, O_3 and O_4) to be four circles such that \omega_i and \omega_{i+1} are externally tangent for all 1 \le i \le 4 where indices are considered \pmod{4}.

We shall refer to the following diagram for notation. Since most labels are not standard, the precise definition of each point is given where it is introduced.

A summary of the key results pertaining to this configuration,

  1. Points L,M,N and K denote the tangency points of each pair of circles. An easy angle chase or an inversion about L shows that quadrilateral LMNK is degenerate or cyclic, which is Problem 24 in Chapter 8 of Evan Chen’s EGMO and has also appeared as 2004 Indonesia MO Problem 4.
    • Moreover, this implies that the length of the tangents from LM \cap KN to \omega_2 and \omega_4 as well as the length of the tangents from LK \cap MN to \omega_1 and \omega_2 are equal, which is the statement of 1999 Argentina TST Problem 2.
    • Since the sum of opposite sides of O_1O_2O_3O_4 is equal to the sum of the radii of the circles, by Pitot’s theorem it follows that O_1O_2O_3O_4 is a tangential quadrilateral.
    • Clearly, the perpendicular bisector of segment LK is the internal \angle O_4O_1O_2 bisector and similarly, so it follows that the circumcenter O of LMNK coincides with the incenter of O_1O_2O_3O_4.
    • Congruency arguments show that LMNK is a rectangle if and only if \omega_1,\omega_3 and \omega_2,\omega_4 are pairs of equiradial circles. In particular, when this happens O_1O_2O_3O_4 is a rhombus, and the incircle of this rhombus coincides with (LMNK). In this case, the antipodes of L, M, N and K in \omega_1,\omega_2,\omega_3 and \omega_4 (whenever they are defined) all lie on an ellipse with center O.
    • Strengthening this observation, LMNK is a square if and only if all four circles are equiradial, which is asked in 2014 Kukin MO Grade 10 Problem 3.
  2. For any point P \in \{L,M,N,K\} denote by I_P the incenter of the triangle formed by the other three points.
    • By the Incenter/Excenter lemma it follows that quadrilateral LMI_KI_N (and similarly) is concyclic with circumcenter coinciding with the minor LM arc midpoint in (LMNK).
    • Further, an easy angle chase shows that all angles of quadrilateral I_MI_NI_KI_L are right and hence a rectangle.
  3. For any point P \in \{L,M,N,K\} denote by H_P the orthocenter of the triangle formed by the other three points.
    • It is not hard to see that quadrilateral LMH_KH_N (and similarly) is concyclic, and that quadrilateral H_MH_NH_KH_L is also concyclic.
    • The quadrilaterals H_MK_KMK (and similarly) are all parallelograms, which implies that the segments H_MM,H_LL, H_NN and H_KK concur, bisecting each other. This claim is in fact also true for any set of four concyclic points.

1 thought on “Four Kissing Circles”

Leave a comment